When we arrived I met "The Princess" and discovered she had two very small children. She also had a very tragic story to tell. It was incredibly sad and had happened during their time away. Photos were propped up on the mantle piece to recognize and remember a child who never came home from the hospital. I think back to that day now and hope I didn't say something incredibly insensitive, I was young and single and until I had children I really had no idea of how a child could break a parents heart. I think I thought that babies were kind of like cars or houses, yes you loved them and found them special, but surely you'd just grieve, move on and then get another one? I was a late bloomer when it came to emotional development.
It wasn't until I held my own child that I learnt there is no baby like your baby. Whether you personally gave birth or waited to hear the news that there was a baby for you - the minute you held it, saw it or even perceived it, your brain made a gear change, an audible clunk. Different speed, a different road.
In retrospect, when I think back to those first six months after my first child was born, I can recognize some of those tell tale signs that are often linked with postpartum depression. I wasn't so much worried that I would intentionally hurt my baby, I was worried that I'd mess up somehow and break her. I had regular nightmares about terrible things happening to her. I'd daydream that I'd accidentally dropped her while walking down the stairs, and then quietly dread that it must have been some sort of vision or warning. I'd stand in the kitchen and imagine how easy it would be to burn her. I check on her in the middle of the night to make sure she was breathing. I know I'm not the only one who did this, I've sat with women all over the world who've had the same discussion. A few of us nervously laughing it off while feeling instant relieved that we weren't alone. None of us quite believing that we were capable of taking our minds there. None of us understanding why it was happening.
Eventually the regularity of those dreams and thoughts stopped, but even now, thirteen years later, I'll occasionally wake up in terror, and for a split second be sure that the dream was real. A child drowned, a child thrown out of a car, or trapped in a fire. I've put it down to motherhood, that something changed in me the day I held my first child, that it's some sort of animal instinct, or maybe just an internal unconscious fear.
I read a post this morning written by a father who talked of discussions that were had about his wife choosing to stay home with the children. He was fierce in his defence of their decision and puzzled by the comments of those in his day to day interactions. The usual comments, we've all heard them before:
“...I can’t imagine being a stay at home mom. I would get so antsy. [Giggles] What does she DO all day?”
His article was heartfelt and as I made my way through it I was imagining the comments he was going to receive from his post. Over the past few years there's been enough written about Stay at Home versus Work at Home versus Go to Work, that you know exactly where the discussion is going to end. Same shit, different shovel. The comments will break into three groups:
Those who stay at home and feel the need to defend it.
Those who go to work and feel the need to defend it.
And those who are batshit crazy and are just angry about everything.
I know what people with babies and toddlers do all day. I've done it. And I know what people who work all day do because I did that too. And I also know what people who talk about other people's decisions do, because unfortunately I've done that as well. It's ugly and its judging. And nothing good can come of it.
But this is what I have learnt when we talk about these perceived "Princesses". There's always a story behind the fairytale and it's usually sad. We all need goals to achieve to be happy, that's how life works. It's all about endorphins and rewards, feeling sadness over not being where we want to be and then great happiness when we get there. That's how our brains work. I'm not talking huge achievements, for some it's just getting something completed, for others it's gradually learning a craft. If you don't achieve anything you don't get the dopamine that comes with the achievement. Life is flat, pointless.
Some of us can work 70 hours a week, run marathons and raise beautiful children - many of us can't, some of us don't want to. But more importantly, none of us know how we're going to react until we're there. Until you're holding your child, you don't know how you're going to feel.
We all have our own goals, our own achievements - and when we don't that's usually when we start feeling miserable. It has nothing to do with the economics of staying at home or going to work. As long as we have something that we're working on for ourselves, that's all that matters. The only thing that's important about what you do all day, is the question of if it is providing the endorphins to keep you happy.
Stick together ladies, while we keep having these ridiculous discussions and judging each others choices, we're wasting time we could have spent on ourselves.
Hello K, that was a refreshing and much needed read. What is this 'judging & comparing' thing about? I agree we make our choices - but some are made for us - yet as long as there's something that's helps a woman be the woman she hopes & wants to be life can be ok. Around 35 years ago my then 30 y o husband was told to medically retire from his teaching role. I had never set out not to work (I am a nicer mother for being at school!) ..there was nothing else for me to do after this major home life event but to take myself on the leadership career path. Interesting about the backstory to everyone's loves. One day I could sit and catch up with you for ages! Your beach house kitchen methinks! Denyse xxx
ReplyDeleteThis is the best opinion piece I have read yet on this issue. You nailed it. And, without knowing what you were like when you met The Princess, I'm sure she would appreciate the growth in your empathy now.
ReplyDeleteCome over for a cuppa anytime Denyse! Exactly, everyone has a story behind their decisions and most of the time I reckon they're made for us. xx
ReplyDeleteAnn-Marie, that is such a lovely to say. Thank you xx
ReplyDeletePerfect piece in so many ways Kirsty xx
ReplyDeleteThis is such a hotly discussed topic, and I honestly think the reason women are so intolerant and judgmental of each other is that many of us are worried and insecure about our *own* choices. When someone makes a different choice than we do, it throws the two choices into contrast, and the instinct is to compare them. If we tear down others' choices, our choice becomes, by default, the better one. Not sure why that must be: can't it just be the 'other' choice? Very thoughtful and well-expressed post.
ReplyDeleteLove this post and it's true for just about any situation in life. We never really know what goes in behind closed doors, so who are we to judge? But judge we do.
ReplyDeleteMy husband and I have our reasons for me staying at home. I know there are many who think I'm a princess for having a glam life in Dubai as a sahm and others who think I'm "crazy" and a "martyr" for not having help/a maid. I'll happily discuss my reasons if asked, not often asked though.
No woman should have to justify the choices she makes. We have a responsibility to give our children the best possible care - but how we do that is for each woman to decide. Some will stay and home, love it, and their children will grow into responsible, rounded young people. Others will find the best child care they can and return to work, and their children will grow into responsible, rounded young people. We love them, we do our best. We do not need to justify ourselves nor judge each other.
ReplyDeleteThis is exactly why I love reading your blog. So many great points, but for me the best line is - "As long as we have something that we're working on for ourselves, that's all that matters".
ReplyDeleteThank you for this post Kirsty.
x
I grew up thinking I'd love to be (and will certainly be) a stay-at-home mom. Then 9 years ago we had our first child, and 8 weeks later when I had to return to work was probably the third or fourth best day of my life at that time. And at the same time I was crushed , feeling I was failing my own dreams. Then few months later I became an expat-non working spouse, and few years later and 2 more kids under the belt, I am still a stay-at-home mom. A role I am not always enjoying, but on the other hand, I will not for a million dollars go back to work and leave my own Little Travellers being raised only by schools and baby sitters. The topic is hot and steamy but I stand my ground on one point: if given the opportunity and the financial stability, I rather stay and watch the development of our 3 kids, be an active part of that process of (hopefully) building great characters, because where's the point of having kids if you are not giving them the best of you. Yes. One day they'll leave, or won't need me anymore, nonetheless, I ll know (and so will they) I had given them, and not to some famous or obscure corporation, my best.
ReplyDelete