I did something really naughty the other night.
I told someone to bugger off. Actually it was worse than that, but my mother reads this blog which she then prints out for my Father so we'll just pretend I said bugger.
It wasn't my intention to be so vocal, but listening to a man who began so many of his sentences with "the problem with women" or "you women" had taken its toll.
It was a conversation about social media, it was about websites and commenting, about how a local women's forum had become a nasty space. "It's women - women just get like that when they're online, they're the worst ones for bullying"
And that's when I told him to swiftly go and make love to himself.
There's no doubt in some cases, commenting online has become a blood sport - but please don't try and tell me its gender specific. We all know why and how it happens, we all mourn the loss of the intelligent commenter who's had three days to prepare his/her response. Gone are the days of searching the house to find a decent piece of paper and pen allowing you time to ponder your eloquent and well thought out response. Anger that was once soothed by the time it took to riffle through the kitchen cupboards looking for a spare stamp and making the walk to the mailbox, has now been replaced by an instant, enraged "you suck".
We all get it. We know it, and surely we know both men and women are guilty of it. When it comes to social media behaviour are men and women all that different?
I began reading Katie Roiphe's article in the FT "disappearing mothers" and was surprised to read her theory. Mothers who have their children's pictures as their Facebook profiles are "disappearing mothers". Really? That's why we're disappearing? Not because we continue to be paid less? Not because we're trying to keep up with work force trends while taking time to slip out of the office and give birth before anyone's noticed we've gone? Not because the media continue to pitch advertising to women who stay at home as brainless, cleaning obsessed, halfwits? Not because women who have chosen to stay home with children, are still wondering how exactly to answer that "so what do you do?" question after being ignored at dinner parties?
I had to go and check for myself.
Out of 384 friends, four have solely children as their profile shots. Two women, two men. Do I warn the men that they too are disappearing? And what about my friend Dave, he has a stuffed kangaroo staring forlornly out of the window. What does that say about him? And my friends who have pictures of other peoples children? Is that okay?
"the whole idea behind Facebook is to create a social persona, an image of who you are projected into hundreds of bedrooms and cafés and offices across the country."
Is it really Katie? I thought Facebook was about staying connected and sharing news, ideas and information?
If life is a series of stories, my current chapter is overloaded with paragraphs on motherhood - and although the motherhood component will never stop, my life with toddlers, tweens and teens will. At this point in my story I am knee deep in soccer schedules, trombones, piano lessons and shit I forgot to sign the consent form. I text guitar teachers, sit on small chairs in classrooms listening to presentations on math homework, and negotiate whether we will do swimming lessons or tennis. I also read books, write articles, have breakfast with girlfriends, watch marathons of Downton Abbey and think about going to the gym.
This chapter is moving much faster than I'd hoped, the next page appears to turn before I've really had a chance to savour the last sentence of the previous one. I gave birth to my twelve year only two weeks ago - seriously, its gone that quickly. I cling to each paragraph, knowing that this story will finish and I will begin a new one.
This is a chapter I should be proud of, one I should be able to share with my friends without judgement. I am a feminist, a mother, a writer, and I have dreams for both myself, and my children.
I am not disappearing.




Fantastic post. Love how you eviscerated, er critiqued, the article as well as the sexist commenter.
ReplyDeleteYou're certainly not! Few more astute observers of the world than you K, truly. Brilliantly said. X
ReplyDeleteLOVE this, and agree whole heartedly! As my eldest approaches
ReplyDelete10 my middle child 8 and my youngest 6, I'm clawing at the memories of their childhood trying My hardest to hold on! I finally have learned that being "just" a mum is ok, it's beautiful and be damned I'll let anyone haunt those amazing Moments ahead with a message I should be worried about disappearing! I'm head to toe engrossed with being a mum and I don't mind one bit :)
Hear hear. Love it.
ReplyDeleteHear hear. Love it.
ReplyDeleteWhat an outrageous article! FT's, not yours. She's just jealous, of course.
ReplyDeleteJealous?
DeleteHer article is cods-whallop, I say.
ReplyDeleteI feel the pressure a lot more now I am living in Hong Kong (compared to Australia) about being "only a mum". But I am proud to raise my kids. I know my husband and I are the two best people on the planet to raise our children, and I am so lucky and grateful to be able to do this, I do not have to go back to work at the moment (even though I am now selling some of my sewing creations to make a little extra cash for me and my fabric habit).
I don't want a stranger raising them (this is my choice) it is so normal here with the maid/helpers almost everyone has (apart from us!)
I am sick of people being so judgey judgey. I wont judge your decisions, so dont judge mine. Just get on with living your life, you only get one.
And he deserved the F word!
Sometimes I think people should read over what they write before they post it.
ReplyDeleteAnd I agree that men can be just as bitchy as women, in fact, in my experience they are more so. I comment quite a lot on Huffington Post and it's usually people with male-sounding pen names that really get nasty. BUT half of them don't even read the comment they're ripping apart. I just got lambasted by someone who read "specified" as "special" and his whole rant was about something that I never even said. Sigh.
I'm not a mother (yet) but I'm saving this post when (hopefully) I am. Very well said.
ReplyDeleteGood for you - we are women, doing all the capable things that women do, and rightly proud of it. I find it depressing that we are still having to make this point - it all felt very new and excited in the sixties (I was there) and I hoped we'd all be behaving like equal grown-ups by now. Sadly, not always. It's essential that women continue to stand up as feminists - with all the complexities that word implies!
ReplyDeleteAnd if men don't like that - it says more about them that it does about us.
Another great post, Kirsty. I don't have a lot of time this visit, just popping in to say that I really enjoy reading this blog. I look forward to a new story in my inbox whenever you care to write one. I've given you a blog award. Participate or not, it's OK, just wanted you to know you're appreciated.
ReplyDeleteI am among the last generation of mothers who thought we were supposed to disappear. Once upon a time we really did give up our selves to being wives and mothers. It's hard to find yourself again if you do that. I once again wish I had my old t-shirt that said, "Every mother is a working mother" to show my support for all of you still choosing to raise your own children. I applaud your ability nowadays to hang on to self while doing that.
ReplyDeleteOh dear, oh dear. When will these ninnies learn that we don't need the Mommy Wars, Working Mother vs. (what the hell do they think stay-at-home mothers are doing??) Stay-at-Home Mother Wars, Breastfeeding vs. Bottle Wars, HomeSchool vs. Public vs. Private School Wars, Disposable vs. Cloth Diaper Wars or any other silly wars started and perpetuated by others. It's small-minded and simply takes precious time away from our other pursuits, goals, objectives, dreams. Disappearing? Hardly.
ReplyDeleteKirsty, I have just discovered your blog after an article of yours appeared on Mamamia in Australia today. I've only read a few posts so far, but just want to tell you how interesting, well written and funny your writing is! As someone who is about to become an expat (we might be moving from Australia to Singapore in January), I will read on through your archives with great interest. Thanks for sharing all your experiences!
ReplyDeleteWhat i don't realize is if truth be told how you are no longer actually a lot more smartly-favored than you might be now. You are very intelligent. You understand thus considerably in the case of this matter, made me in my opinion believe it from numerous varied angles. Its like women and men aren't interested unleѕs іt
ReplyDeleteis onе thing to accomplish wіth Girl
gaga! Your own stuffѕ outѕtanding. All the time hanԁle іt up!
Feel free to vіsit my homepage Exchange Programs
My website :: study abroad in italy